Affordability leads the agenda for Matt Crowley and AJ Shearer in Peterborough’s Monaghan Ward

In the fourth instalment of kawarthaNOW's ward-by-ward series, the returning councillor and newcomer discuss taxes, housing, and measuring results

Re-elected with a historic mandate for his second term as Monaghan Ward councillor, Matt Crowley will be joined by first-time councillor AJ Shearer to represent the ward for the 2026-2030 term of Peterborough city council. (kawarthaNOW collage)
Re-elected with a historic mandate for his second term as Monaghan Ward councillor, Matt Crowley will be joined by first-time councillor AJ Shearer to represent the ward for the 2026-2030 term of Peterborough city council. (kawarthaNOW collage)

Following the municipal election on October 26, Peterborough residents have voted in five incumbent councillors and five new faces on council, in addition to the new mayor-elect Michael Eamon.

In Monaghan Ward, incumbent councillor Matt Crowley easily won his re-election campaign with 5,301 votes — the most votes of any councillor across all of the city’s five wards.

With incumbent councillor Don Vassiliadis deciding not to run for re-election, five first-time candidates competed for the empty seat. Monaghan Ward residents chose to elect AJ Shearer with 2,241 votes.

Before the new council is inaugurated on Thursday (November 19), kawarthaNOW asked councillors-elect in each of the city’s five wards to explain how they will take action to address the most pressing issues raised by residents during the campaign period, by asking them three questions:

  • The draft 2027 budget will be presented on November 30. What are your financial priorities at this stage?
  • Once council enters session, what will your priorities be and how will you take action on these?
  • Throughout the campaign period, many residents identified housing shortages as a primary concern. How will you directly address the homelessness crisis?

Each councillor-elect was also asked two further questions, based on their incumbency status and previous comments made to kawarthaNOW throughout the campaign period.

Advertisement - content continues below

 

 

Crowley seeks to balance affordability with infrastructure needs and economic growth

Building on his success as a political novice in 2022 when he received the most votes of any candidate in Monaghan Ward, Crowley will enter his second term with residents of the ward again solidly behind him.

“I would like to think that the historic mandate that I was given at this past election has a lot to do with how responsive I’ve been,” Crowley told kawarthaNOW. “I think being accessible is the most important part of being a councillor.”

Crowley said that, going into this term, he will continue to respond to the concerns of his constituents and that his top priority, affordability, reflects the conversations he had at the door with residents throughout the campaign period.

In particular, Crowley said, West End residents are concerned about rising property taxes and the cost of living. Crowley noted that the demographic of Monaghan Ward consists primarily of seniors and families who are often heavily impacted by affordability challenges.

However, Crowley said he recognizes the reality of municipal operational expenses and requirements that are regulated by the provincial government.

“We still need to maintain roads and sidewalks and infrastructure, and I don’t think that we want to defer a lot of that work and services, because it would just mean that they would get more expensive in the long run,” Crowley said.

Alongside affordability, Crowley said his other priorities are homelessness and economic development, noting these priorities are shared by other elected officials in Peterborough as well as municipalities across the province. He said the three priorities are closely related.

“Those three things aren’t actually completely separate issues. They’re all actually connected, and you change something about one and it has a ripple effect on the others.”

Crowley said he supports the city taking economic development in-house, a decision that followed the city’s 2024 announcement that it was ending its funding agreement with the now-dissolved Peterborough & the Kawarthas Economic Development (PKED), a non-profit organization that managed economic development and tourism on behalf of the city and Peterborough County.

However, he said he wants to see results from the city’s new approach to economic development that would enable council to limit increases to the residential property tax, which currently accounts for around 88 per cent of the city’s net operating revenues.

“How many businesses are we attracting? How many jobs were created? Are we growing our commercial tax base? We need more robust reporting moving forward to ensure that economic development is actually doing what it can.”

Advertisement - content continues below

 

 

Housing, provincial action on poverty, and accessible representation remain Crowley’s priorities

On the issue of housing and homelessness, Crowley spoke to a number of approaches to affordability but also said there is a significant role to be played by the provincial government that has “downloaded” the costs of homelessness onto municipalities through a lack of action on addressing the root causes of poverty.

Late in the previous council term, Crowley brought forward a motion advocating that the provincial government explore guaranteed basic income to prevent people from slipping into homelessness.

“We can keep spending money dealing with the consequences of poverty, but we really need the provincial government to step up and start taking greater responsibility for addressing the causes of poverty,” he said. “The province can’t keep leaving municipalities like ours to deal with some of these downloaded costs that we associate with homelessness and mental health or addictions.”

In terms of activities within the scope of the municipality, Crowley said he is an advocate for housing intensification, transitional housing opportunities, and rent-geared-to-income units.

“Building market-rate housing isn’t going to solve homelessness directly, but my hope is that if you add more housing to the continuum it’s less competition for homes. It’s less pressure on housing prices and rents over time.”

“We just need to keep adding housing to the housing continuum. And I think intensification and strategic growth areas are really important to do that.”

A defining feature of Crowley’s first term on council was his public visibility and responsiveness, including on Facebook and other social media platforms.

“It’s been really valuable,” Crowley reflects. “I think some of the most important issues that I’ve worked on over the last four years have started out as a Facebook or an Instagram message.”

Crowley told kawarthaNOW that he intends to continue using social media and direct forms of communication, both to keep residents informed and to respond to their concerns in a timely and direct manner.

“The biggest lesson that I have learned as a councillor is ensuring that your constituents feel like you’re responsive, that you’re communicative, and that you’re listening to them,” he said. “I think that everybody just really wants to feel that their voice is heard.”

Advertisement - content continues below

 

 

Shearer prepares for his first term through collaboration and a focus on affordability

As for Shearer, the political newcomer defeated four other first-time candidates to take the second seat for Monaghan Ward. The real estate broker received less than half of the votes that Crowley did, but edged out custom home building company owner Ashley Flynn by 306 votes.

Shearer told kawarthaNOW that the biggest issue facing Monaghan residents is affordability, and that the challenges seen in his ward are reflective of experiences across the country, especially when it comes to the state of the economy.

“There are a number of things that the whole country, let alone Peterborough, is up against,” Shearer said.

Like Crowley, he also expressed concerns about the long-term sustainability of the city relying on residential taxpayers for revenue.

Shearer admitted that, as a first-time councillor, he has a steep learning curve when it comes to understanding how best to balance the needs of the community with a sustainable budget.

“This is my first time taking a kick at it, so there’s going to be plenty of things that I’ve got absolutely no clue about,” he said. “I’m going to be relying on the experts and my other councillors who’ve been around for some advice there.”

Shearer said he has already met with almost all other newly elected members of council and connected with the unsuccessful candidates in Monaghan Ward to establish a network of experts.

“I’m also personally working on a few thought processes from a systems perspective,” he said, adding that he intends to work closely with his ward mate. “Personally I’d love to be able to put something together where Matt and I can collaborate and hopefully maintain the fantastic level of service that he’s been able to provide the ward.”

Advertisement - content continues below

 

 

Measuring results and encouraging housing investment guide Shearer’s approach

With a background in engineering and data analysis, Shearer said he wants to use his experience to “tie the money that we’re spending to the outcomes that we’re getting from various departments.”

“How much does each one of those results end up costing us as a taxpayer?” he asked.

Shearer said that he heard from residents who are frustrated with rising tax bills when there seems to be a lack of progress in key areas, and that he would use this analysis to determine the return on investment from residential tax revenue.

“It is hard for them to relate their increasing tax bills to the level of service that they receive,” he said.

On the issue of housing, Shearer said that one challenge will be to assess Peterborough’s long-term need for affordable units and the types of projects developers undertake.

“I’d like to say that we could mandate some level of more affordable housing, but to be perfectly honest, that’s one where I don’t understand the leverage enough,” he said. “There’s got to be some way to find some wins in there, to incentivize people (to build affordable housing).”

Previously, Shearer told kawarthaNOW that “council must find practical ways to encourage investment while ensuring that growth contributes to our city’s infrastructure and quality of life.”

He reiterated that point during the interview, explaining that his goal is to ensure that developers are engaging in a mutually beneficial relationship that strengthens Peterborough’s capacity and infrastructure.

“Anybody that we’re bringing into town, I want to make sure that they’ve got skin in the game,” Shearer said. “When you talk about different developers and different industries coming into town, what way can we create a partnership so that they feel invested in Peterborough and they feel that Peterborough is investing in them?”