Charlie Glasspool's 3C84 project was inspired by the NGC 1275 galaxy, located 237 million light-years from Earth, which contains one of the brightest radio sources in the sky. This image of NGC 1275, taken in 2006 using the NASA/ESA Hubble Space Telescope's Advanced Camera for Surveys, shows the fine thread-like filaments in the 100-million-degree Fahrenheit hot gas surrounding the galaxy, which are markers of the feedback process through which energy is transferred from the galaxy's central massive black hole to the surrounding gas. (Image: NASA/ESA)
Fans of music and stargazing will have the opportunity to fulfill both desires Friday night (May 5) at 9 p.m. with ‘3C84: Music Under the Stars’ in performance at the top of Armour Hill on the opening night of Artsweek Peterborough.
Featuring Charlie Glasspool, Jose Contreras, Victoria Yeh, Susan Newman, Evangeline Gentle, and Jessie Pilgrim, 3C84 perfectly encompasses Artsweek’s theme this year of ‘art in unexpected places’ in that it is inspired by and named after a distant radio source, located in the Perseus A galaxy approximately 237 million light-years away from Earth, that emits a constant subsonic B flat.
The idea that this note should be a tuning note struck Glasspool as rather poetic and led him to feel compelled to “send a message back to where the B flat is coming from” as a tribute to the intergalactic universality of music. That inspiration led to the recording of an album, aptly titled b, which was released in 2008.
Advertisement - content continues below
Share on Bluesky
“A lot of the pieces are not necessarily about the galaxy NGC 1275, as it was called, but they’re definitely reflective in nature, about human existence,” Glasspool said in a phone interview with kawarthaNOW. “Some of the pieces are about space, some are about what it’s like to be alive.”
A previous member of the Silver Hearts, an instrumental music teacher and band director, and a collaborator with innumerable musicians, Glasspool has returned to Peterborough, saying that he had “felt its pull like a blackhole” and has recently found himself playing as part of Evangeline Gentle’s band.
The breadth of themes on the b album and its emphasis on the subjectivity of human experiences is apparent in a track like “When I Was Dead,” which serves as a meditation on the inevitability of death alongside mundane tasks of living like paying rent and missing the sublime experiences of love and connection with other people, thereby aligning both as equal experiences.
VIDEO: “When I Was Dead” – 3C48 (video by LA Alfonso)
As Glasspool recalls, the first time he heard about the 3C84 was from Ian Osbourne, who at the time ran the soundboard at the Gordon Best Theatre above The Only Café in downtown Peterborough.
“He always seemed to have an encyclopedic knowledge of kind of unusual things,” Glasspool said. “I guess what really grabbed me as someone who maybe is a bit sentimental — it’s just curious to me to b flat. I grew up playing in concert bands and wind orchestras and conducting them later in life. And that’s the note that you tune to.”
The opportunity to bring 3C84 back into existence came when Su Ditta of Electric City Culture Council called Glasspool asking if he would revisit the project for Artsweek.
Advertisement - content continues below
Share on Bluesky
“Given the nature of the project, I think it’s kind of fitting,” Glasspool said. “I’m also not terribly interested anymore in like ‘This is a band, we’re at a bar, we play a show, the end’. I’m more interested in music in alternative spaces.”
The performance takes place Friday night at the Heritage Pavilion Stage on Armour Hill, and attendees are encouraged to bring a telescope if they have one.
Beyond the recording, Glasspool could only think of two or three times 3C84 has performed the material. However, Glasspool recalls the group connecting with the Peterborough Astronomy Club, who would run impromptu tutorials on using telescopes, citing one performance that took place on Armour Hill as part of Astronomy Day on May 26, 2007.
“I always wanted this music to kind of be a soundtrack to stargazing,” Glasspool said, explaining the vision behind the outdoor performance and 3C84’s hopes for clear skies on the night of the concert.
3C84 performing at the Heritage Pavilion Stage on Armour Hill in Peterborough on May 26, 2007. Along with composer Charlie Glasspool (keyboard and vocals), the original band members included Laurie Deratnay (flute, synthesizer, vocals), Dan Fortin (bass), Jesse Pilgrim (theremin), and Sue Newman, Sarah McInnis, and Misha Paramonov (vocals). (kawarthaNOW screenshot of LA Alfonzo video)
Glasspool couldn’t help but speak in astronomical terms when discussing the resurrection of his 15-year-old collaborative project.
“I kind of gravitate to working with others,” he said. “Music for me is a kind of a community experience and something to share with others.”
Glasspool says free copies of 3C84’s b album will be distributed to attendees following the May 5th performance. The show itself will be a top-to-bottom recreation of the original 11-song album, which is available for streaming and a digital download on Glasspool’s Bandcamp page.
Advertisement - content continues below
Share on Bluesky
Glasspool says he is thrilled by the opportunity to revisit material which hasn’t been played for over a decade and to do so alongside some of those who were involved in the original incarnation of 3C84. Besides Glasspool, Jessie Pilgrim and Susan Newman are among the artists involved in the original recording project, alongside the album’s producer Jose Contreras.
“Maybe it didn’t get a fair shake the first time,” Glasspool said, adding that perhaps getting it back together with some of the original members in the same room will regenerate or rejuvenate the project or perhaps act as a springboard for another project.
Besides wondering how the material would hold up after so many years, Glasspool has also been reflecting on how his relationship with the material has changed. For example, he said songs that were deeply personal when they were first written now feel like they’re about someone else entirely.
3C84’s album “b” is available for streaming and digital download from Charlie Glasspool’s Bandcamp page. Copies of the album will be distributed to attendees following the band’s May 5, 2023 performance. (Image courtesy of Charlie Glasspool)
Specifically, Glasspool pointed to the song “And Me” which was written about an unhappy relationship and now sounds like it could have been written about some megalomaniacal figure like Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos who shoots themselves into space for fun.
Picking up on this theme is the track “Yuri Gagarin’s Lullaby” about the first human being to venture into outer space aboard the Vostok 1 capsule in 1961.
As human ingenuity and scientific achievement reach their peak, it ultimately leaves the lonesome adventurer swearing to give up his helmet, air, and view for his mother’s cabbage stew as we are left with the poignant single-lined chorus “I looked but I could not see God.”
Advertisement - content continues below
“Fifteen years ago, I was maybe a little more, I don’t know, not conceited, but maybe a little more self-centred,” Glasspool said, chuckling a little bit as he reflects on the passage of time and the opportunity to revisit this material, and how he views the subject of space and the stars as grounds for fostering rich conversation amongst audiences.
Naturally, that is exactly what Glasspool is hoping will occur on May 5th as Artsweek kicks off with the opportunity to reach beyond the visible stars and answer the inaudible hum of the universe through music and community.
3C84 performs on the Heritage Pavilion Stage on Armour Hill at the Peterborough Museum & Archives from 9 to 10 p.m. on Friday, May 5th. As with all Artsweek Peterborough events, the perfrmance is free. For more information about Artsweek and a full schedule of events, visit artsweekpeterborough.ca.
VIDEO: “Let’s See What My Telescope Says” – 3C84 (video by LA Alfonso)
kawarthaNOW is proud to be the official media sponsor of Artsweek Peterborough 2023.
The southbound lane of Television Raod in Peterborough will be closed between Parkhill Road East in the north and Maniece Avenue in the south from May 3 to 17, 2023 for road repaving. Drivers heading south to get to Highway 7 and Highway 115 will need to use another route. (Photo: Google Earth)
Drivers heading southbound on Television Road in Peterborough to get to Highway 7 and Highway 115 will need to use another route for two weeks starting Wednesday (May 3).
Television Road is being repaved between Parkhill Road East in the north and Maniece Avenue in the south from May 3 to 17.
The southbound lane will be closed during the work, and southbound traffic will be redirected to follow posted detour routes during the temporary lane closure. The northbound lane will remain open.
Advertisement - content continues below
Parkhill Road East traffic looking to go south on Television Road to Lansdowne Street East will be redirected east towards the Parkhill Road East and Armour Road intersection.
Drivers can then head south along Armour Road to Maria Street, east on Maria Street to Ashburnham Drive, south on Ashburnham Drive to Lansdowne Street East, and then east on Lansdowne Street East to Television Road at Highway 7/115.
The road work will include pulverizing existing bituminous pavement, earth excavation and grading, installing new base and surface course hot mix asphalt, adjusting catch basins, and applying pavement markings on Television Road between Parkhill Road East and Maniece Avenue.
The outdoor Peterborough Regional Farmers' Market takes place at Quaker Foods City Square on Charlotte Street just east of Aylmer Street from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. every Wednesday and Saturday from May 3 to October 28, 2023. (Photo: Peterborough Regional Farmers' Market)
The Peterborough Regional Farmers’ Market opens for the outdoor season at its new home at Quaker Foods City Square in downtown Peterborough on Wednesday (May 3).
The market runs from 8 a.m. to 1 p.m. every Wednesday and Saturday until October 28 and will feature locally grown produce, take-away meals and goodies, artisan wares, and musicians.
Quaker Foods City Square, which officially opened in December, is located on Charlotte Street just east of Aylmer Street. Prior to the construction of the city square, which began in 2017, the site included the Louis Street Municipal Parking Lot, which was the former location of the Wednesday Downtown Farmers’ Market.
Advertisement - content continues below
Share on Bluesky
“We are genuinely excited for this opportunity the City of Peterborough has given us,” says Peterborough Regional Farmers’ Market chair Jeff Wagner in a media release. “There is an understanding as to the importance a vibrant urban market can bring to the Peterborough downtown core. The site is on the former location of the Wednesday market and many vendors are overjoyed to be returning to a location that had a strong and vibrant place in the city. We look forward to a great summer filled with exciting events, and wonderful seasonal products.”
While construction of the Quaker Foods City Square was underway, the outdoor market was held on Charlotte Street at the Peterborough Square courtyard (moving inside the lower level of Peterborough Square during the winter). Quaker Foods City Square offers access to Peterborough Transit with public parking available at the adjacent King Street Parkade, as well as street parking.
“We’re thrilled to have Peterborough Regional Farmers’ Market operating in Quaker Foods City Square,” say Town Ward councillors Alex Bierk and Joy Lachica. “The market fulfills two important roles for our downtown — it provides local produce, prepared food, and local artisans’ work, and perhaps more importantly it helps build a sense of community. It will be a great experience to stroll through the square, pick up some local goodies at the market, and meet up with friends and neighbours.”
Peterborough police are seeking this man suspected of stealing a woman's vehicle at knifepoint from a parking lot at Lansdowne Street and The Parkway on April 30, 2023. (Police-supplied photo)
A man wanted in connection with the carjacking incident in Peterborough was arrested in Windsor on Tuesday (May 2). The 30-year-old man, who is being held in custody, is facing charges in in multiple jurisdictions.
For the Peterborough incident, the man is facing the following charges. robbery with violence, possession of a weapon for dangerous purposes, assault with a weapon, dangerous operation of a motor vehicle, flight from a peace officer, motor vehicle theft, and failing to stop when signalled or requested to do so by a police officer.
Original story
Peterborough police are searching for a suspect after a carjacking in a parking lot at Lansdowne Street and The Parkway on Sunday morning (April 30).
At around 7:45 a.m. on Sunday, officers were called to the parking lot after a woman reported her vehicle was stolen from her at knifepoint. The victim did not require medical attention.
Officers spotted the stolen vehicle on The Parkway and pursued it onto Highway 115, where the vehicle exited the highway and continued north on Highway 7.
Advertisement - content continues below
Officers were unable to safely deploy a spike belt before the vehicle turned onto Lansdowne Street at a high rate of speed and headed back toward the City of Peterborough. Police then called off the pursuit for safety reasons.
Through further investigation, officers identified a pick-up truck the suspect had exited in the parking lot and learned it was reported stolen in Kingston on Saturday evening.
The suspect is described as a white man between 20 and 30 years old, 200 lbs, 5’9″ to 5’11”, unshaven and balding with short light brown hair. He was wearing a large white T-shirt and dark pants.
The stolen vehicle is a black four-door 2010 Toyota Corolla with plate number BNEJ 017.
Anyone with information is asked to call Peterborough Police at 705-876-1122 x555 or Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-8477 or online at stopcrimehere.ca.
The Rotary Club of Peterborough held its annual dinner and auction charity fundraiser at Peterborough Golf & Country Club on April 28, 2023, raising $25,000 for YES Shelter for Youth and Families through a silent and live auction that included original encaustic painting by Rotarian Susan Fisher (left). Also pictured are Rotarian Catherine Hanrahan who emceed the event, auctioneer Rob Rusland, and Rotarian Bruce Gravel, who co-chaired the event with Rotarian Amy Simpson. (Photo: Frances Gravel)
The Rotary Club of Peterborough has raised $25,000 for YES Shelter for Youth and Families’ Rise Youth Housing Program to help teens stay off the streets.
The funds were raised at Rotary’s annual dinner and auction charity fundraiser last Friday night (April 28) at Peterborough Golf & Country Club. It was the club’s first in-person auction in three years.
Almost 90 people attended the event, co-chaired by Rotarians Bruce Gravel and Amy Simpson and emceed by Rotarian Catherine Hanrahan, which featured dinner with wine and appetizers, and live classical music.
The event also include a silent auction and a live auction hosted by local professional auctioneer Rob Rusland, who has led the bidding at the club’s auction every year since 1993 when the event was founded. There were more than 120 items to bid on, including a South African photo safari.
Beyond the money raised for YES Shelter for Youth and Families, auction proceeds will also go to Rotary’s other community projects.
Founded on April 1, 1921, the Rotary Club of Peterborough is Peterborough’s first and oldest service club. In the past, the club has supported many community projects including the Rotary Greenway Trail, Camp Kawartha, Five Counties Children’s Centre, Easter Seals, the education centre at the Riverview Park & Zoo, food programs, and — in collaboration with the Rotary Club of Peterborough Kawartha — the adult outdoor gym at Beavermead Park, Victoria Day and Canada Day fireworks, and Peterborough’s outdoor dog park.
Managed by the Ganaraska Region Conservation Authority (GRCA), the Ganaraska Forest is southern Ontario's largest forest at 11,000 acres (4,452 hectares), straddling Northumberland and Peterborough counties, Kawartha Lakes, and Durham Region. The forest offers hundreds of kilometres of trails for year-round activities including hiking, mountain biking, horseback riding, cross-country skiing, snowshoeing, and nature appreciation. (Photo: GRCA)
Almost a year after the derecho wind storm resulted in wide-spread devastation, the Ganaraska Forest is open effective Monday (May 1) for all non-motorized and motorized uses with a valid membership or day pass.
Managed by the Ganaraska Region Conservation Authority (GRCA), the Ganaraska Forest is southern Ontario’s largest forest at 11,000 acres (4,452 hectares), straddling Northumberland and Peterborough counties, Kawartha Lakes, and Durham Region.
The forest offers hundreds of kilometres of trails for year-round activities including hiking, mountain biking, horseback riding, cross-country skiing, snowshoeing, and nature appreciation. Treetop Trekking Ganaraska independently operates an aerial games course in the central forest.
Advertisement - content continues below
“The Ganaraska Region Conservation Authority is happy to welcome users back into the Ganaraska Forest,” says GRCA chair Mark Lovshin in a media release. “Damage to trails from the derecho wind storm have been addressed by staff, contractors, and volunteers.”
The May 21, 2022 derecho storm, described as the largest natural disaster to ever impact the forest, resulted in over 250 hectares (600 acres) of tree blowdown throughout the forest and significant trail impact from downed trees and hazard trees. The forest reopened last September for restricted use only, with limited trail access for users with memberships.
To help trail users navigate the forest, GRCA has developed an interactive online mapping system where users can find their location in the forest by using a locator tool. The online map also displays any trail restrictions or closures in real time.
To help trail users navigate the Ganaraska Forest, the Ganaraska Region Conservation Authority (GRCA) has developed an interactive online mapping system where users can find their location in the forest by using a locator tool. The online map also displays any trail restrictions or closures in real time. (kawarthaNOW screenshot)
Advertisement - content continues below
Day passes are available at the gatehouse kiosk at the Ganaraska Forest Centre (10585 Cold Springs Camp Road, Campbellcroft). Day passes and memberships can also be purchased online at store.ganaraskaconservation.ca. Memberships purchased made between June 1, 2021 and May 21, 2022 have received a one-year extension.
GRCA reminds all users to stay on mapped trails, respect trail restrictions, carry your day pass or membership with you, and ensure you have the proper documentation with you and affixed to your motorized recreational vehicles. To report trail blockages, email volunteer@grca.on.ca with the location and a picture of the blockage.
For more information about the Ganaraska Forest and to review the forest rules and guidelines, visit www.grca.on.ca.
Canadian drum legend Paul DeLong wears a Mahavishnu Orchestra T-shirt, in honour of the jazz fusion band that inspired him to become a musician 50 years to the day when he brings his own jazz fusion band ONE WORD to the Gordon Best Theatre in downtown Peterborough on May 4, 2023. (Photo: Trevor Hesselink / Groundswell Photography)
Canadian drum legend Paul DeLong will be bringing his jazz fusion band ONE WORD to Peterborough’s Gordon Best Theatre for one night only on Thursday (May 4).
That’s 50 years to the day that the Juno award-winning DeLong — best known for his multi-platinum success with rocker Kim Mitchell — saw the Mahavishnu Orchestra live in concert for the first time, inspiring him to become a musician.
Formed by English guitarist John McLaughlin, the Mahavishnu Orchestra became one of the most important and high-profile bands in jazz fusion, a music genre that developed in the late 1960s when musicians began combining jazz harmony and improvisation with rock, funk, and rhythm and blues.
Advertisement - content continues below
“My mind was blown,” recalls DeLong. “I had never heard anything like them before. It’s still the heaviest experience of my life.”
DeLong has since forged a career encompassing the funk, fusion, jazz, and Latin genres and, in addition to Kim Mitchell, has worked with other legendary artists including Domenic Troiano, Lawrence Gowan (Styx), David Clayton-Thomas (Blood, Sweat and Tears), Roger Hodgson (Supertramp), Tom Scott (L.A. Express), and David Blamires (Pat Metheny).
Five years ago, the Toronto-based DeLong formed his own jazz fusion band ONE WORD, which performs music from the Mahavishnu Orchestra along with other jazz fusion greats including Chick Corea’s Return to Forever, Allan Holdsworth, Weather Report, the late guitarist Jeff Beck, jazz violinist Jean-Luc Ponty, and more.
VIDEO: Paul DeLong’s ONE WORD
Advertisement - content continues below
Award-winning electric violinist Victoria Yeh, who recently moved from Toronto to Peterborough and has been performing regularly around the city, is one of the members of ONE WORD, along with Grammy nominee Steve Lucas on bass, Michael Murray on guitar, and veteran Toronto keyboardist Don Baird.
Yeh promises an “unforgettable night of fusion” when ONE WORD performs at the Gordon Best on Thursday, May 4th. General admission tickets are $35 in advance or $40 at the door, with VIP tickets (including a pre-show meet and greet with the band and preferred seating) available for $55 in advance only.
Advance tickets are available now at victoriayeh.com/oneword/. Doors open at 7 p.m. with the show beginning at 7:30 p.m.
If you miss the ONE WORD concert, you can also catch DeLong when he performs at Showplace Performance Centre with the Chicago tribute band Brass Transit on Sunday, May 28th and again with the iconic Canadian rock band Lighthouse on Saturday, June 10th.
Award-winning electric violinist Victoria Yeh, who recently moved from Toronto to Peterborough, will be performing with Paul DeLong’s ONE WORD at the Gordon Best Theatre in downtown Peterborough on May 4, 2023. (Photo: Trevor Hesselink / Groundswell Photography)
Champion Canadian swimmer Penny Oleksiak is the spokesperson for the annual Tim Hortons Smile Cookie campaign, taking place this spring for the first time. Oleksiak is a long-time advocate of Smile Cookie who volunteered to decorate cookies at her local Tim Hortons when she was younger. (Photo: Tim Hortons)
The annual Tim Hortons Smile Cookie campaign is taking place this spring for the first time, again raising funds for local charities and community groups including several in the greater Kawarthas region.
Usually held in the fall, this year’s campaign will run from Monday, May 1st to Sunday, May 7th.
In another change, the price of a smile cookie is increasing for the first time in the program’s history, going from $1 to $1.50 per cookie (or $18 for a dozen cookies). All proceeds (before taxes) will still go to local charities and organizations.
Advertisement - content continues below
“This increase will allow even more money to be raised for charities and community groups across the country,” Tim Hortons states on its website.
Tim Hortons locations in the communities listed below will be supporting the following charities and community groups:
City of Peterborough, Lakefield, Bridgenorth, and Curve Lake – Community Care Peterborough
Bancroft – North Hastings District Hospital Auxiliary
Haliburton and Minden – Walkabout Farm Therapeutic Riding Association
Coboconk – Ridgewood Public School Breakfast Program
Fenelon Falls – Fenelon Falls Secondary School Breakfast Program, Langton Public School Breakfast Program
Bobcaygeon – Bobcaygeon Public School Breakfast Program, Dunsford Public School Breakfast Program
Lindsay – Humane Society of Kawartha Lakes, Kawartha Lakes Food Source, The Dragon Flies Breast Cancer Survivor Group
Port Hope – Million Dollar Smiles
Cobourg and Colborne – Big Brothers, Big Sisters of Northumberland
The Tim Hortons Smile Cookie campaign began in 1996 as a way to help raise funds for the Hamilton Children’s Hospital in Ontario. It has since grown to become a major fundraising event at Tim Hortons restaurants, raising more than $75 million for local charities and community groups.
Last fall, the campaign raised a record-breaking $15 million for over 600 local charities and community groups, bringing the 27-year fundraising total to over $90 million.
An estimated 16,000 people crowded Del Crary Park in June 2016 to see Serena Ryder perform on the Fred Anderson Stage. (Screenshot of Cogeco YourTV video)
The City of Peterborough is dismantling the Fred Anderson Stage at Del Crary Park and will install a new stage in time for Peterborough Musicfest’s 36th summer season, which opens on Canada Day with a concert by Natalie MacMaster and Donnell Leahy.
Built in the 1980s, the Fred Anderson Stage — named after the late founder of the Peterborough Festival of Lights, which became Peterborough Musicfest — has hosted hundreds of musicians since the festival was Launched on July 1, 1987.
Last June, just days before Peterborough Musicfest was set to return to Del Crary Park after a two-year pandemic absence, the city inspected the Fred Anderson Stage and deemed it structurally unsafe, banning its use. A temporary stage was constructed at Del Crary Park so Musicfest could proceed with its 2022 season.
Advertisement - content continues below
In the city’s 2023 capital budget, city council approved $200,000 for the purchase of a new stage.
According to a media release from the city, the new stage “will enhance the live entertainment experience at the park with features to meet modern production needs, including allowing for better lighting and sound systems.”
However, unlike the Fred Anderson Stage, the new stage will not be a fixed structure.
“The new stage will be mobile so that potentially it can also be set up at other locations for events,” the media release states.
The Strumbellas perform at Peterborough Musicfest in August 2022 on a temporary stage after the City of Peterborough deemed the the Fred Anderson Stage to be unsafe. The City of Peterborough will install a new mobile stage in time for Musicfest’s 2023 summer season. (Photo: Bruce Head / kawarthaNOW)
Minden residents Patrick Porzuczek, Laura Porzuczek, and Richard Bradley (middle) with NDP health critic France Gélinas (left) and NDP MPP Spadina-Fort York Chris Glover (right) in front of the Legislature at Queen's Park in Toronto on April 27, 2023, where they delivered a petition requesting a moratorium of the decision to close the Minden emergency department on June 1. (Photo via France Gélinas / Facebook)
A week after Haliburton Highlands Health Services announced the Minden emergency department would permanently close on June 1, members of the Minden community were at Queen’s Park in Toronto to deliver a petition to the Ontario government demanding a moratorium of the decision, while officials from Haliburton Highlands Health Services appeared before both the Township of Minden Hills and Haliburton County councils to explain the rationale behind the decision.
On Thursday (April 27), Minden residents Patrick Porzuczek, Laura Porzuczek, and Richard Bradley led a group that travelled to Queen’s Park with a petition — signed by 3,359 Minden-area residents — asking the Ministry of Health and Long Term Care to place a moratorium on the Haliburton Highlands Health Services decision “for a minimum of one year to allow for consultations with all affected stakeholders to occur.”
NDP health critic France Gélinas (MPP Nickle Belt) brought the petition before the Legislature on Thursday afternoon and asked Ontario’s minister of health and long-term care Sylvia Jones during question period whether she would support the moratorium request.
Advertisement - content continues below
Share on Bluesky
“I know that the member opposite knows very well that hospitals are responsible for their day-to-day operations and make those decisions independent of the ministry of health and government,” Jones replied. “We have been assured that the Haliburton Highlands Health Science [sic] board and leadership have made this decision carefully, thoughtfully, understanding and appreciating the needs of their community and their staff, and I will let them do that work.”
Much of the criticism from the Minden community about the decision to close the emergency department revolves around a lack of communication and consultation with the community about the closure and the timing of the closure at the beginning of summer.
“Members of Minden’s community are determined to exhaust all possible options to reverse this hasty and poorly considered decision,” reads a media release issued by the Ontario NDP on Thursday. “There were a staggering 13,000 visits to the (Minden) emergency department in 2022, with the number trending upwards. The town’s population triples during summer due to seasonal residents and tourists. It’s incomprehensible that such a significant decision was made without consulting any stakeholders. This community will not rest until their voices are heard.”
VIDEO: Question Period – April 27, 2023 – Minden emergency department closure
Last Thursday (April 20), Haliburton Highlands Health Services announced the Minden emergency department would be closed effective Friday, June 1st, with all staff to be transferred to the emergency department in Haliburton, shocking Minden-area politicians and residents.
Haliburton Highlands Health Services currently operates two emergency departments that are open 24/7, one at 4575 Deep Bay Road in Minden and the other at 7199 Gelert Road in Haliburton, both with on-site heliports. Unlike the Haliburton location, which has 15 in-patient beds, the Minden location does not offer in-patient acute care services.
Most Minden patients requiring hospitalization are transferred to Haliburton or to hospitals in Lindsay or Bracebridge. With the closure of the Minden emergency department, local residents would need to travel 25 kilometres northeast to Haliburton — a 25-minute drive — for emergency medical services.
According to a statement from Haliburton Highlands Health Services president and CEO Carolyn Plummer and board chair David O’Brien, the decision to close the Minden emergency department was made in response to an ongoing shortage of nursing and medical staff.
Advertisement - content continues below
Share on Bluesky
Both Plummer and O’Brien attended a meeting of the Township of Minden Hills council on Thursday afternoon to give a presentation about the decision and to answer questions from Minden Hills mayor Bob Carter on behalf of members of the community.
“Let me state the reason why this decision was made, and it was made because of the ongoing staffing shortages,” O’Brien said. “It’s taken an extraordinary amount of effort over the last 18 months to keep the team together, to keep it focused, to keep it delivering the services we need. Our staff have made incredible personal and professional sacrifices in order to make that happen.”
“It got to the point that we can’t continue to do that. We’re going to lose people, more than we already lost. We’re going to lose our hospital if we continue to do this — I’m not talking about closing Minden emergency, I’m talking about the broader Haliburton (Haliburton Highlands Health Services) hospital.”
“That was the focus of making this decision,” O’Brien said. “The staff that we have are under extreme pressure. They came to us and said ‘Look, you’ve got to do something because we can’t keep going on like this. The system’s going to fail if we let it go on.’ So that’s kind of the crux of why the decision was made. There are a lot of other things that go into it, but that’s the real important part of the decision.”
For her part, Plummer said she has “spoken about our staffing crisis in every public board meeting for the past couple of years and I have spoken about it with the mayors when we’ve met with them,” adding that there were more than “20 official close calls” in 2022 and “many other close calls that were not made official” where either one or both of the Haliburton and Minden emergency departments would have to close temporarily.
Plummer said the decision to consolidate emergency services at the Haliburton location was made because, unlike the Minden location, Haliburton already has in-patient acute care beds.
“We considered feedback received from the paramedic services, who highlighted the fact that the Haliburton site is more centralized in the county for ambulance travel times,” Plummer said. “We also looked at the fact that maintaining hospital services close to the Haliburton family medical centre has many benefits, primarily facilitating easy access to primary care physicians to see patients in both the emergency department and the in-patient unit.”
Thousands of Minden-area residents have signed a petition to place a moratorium on the Haliburton Highlands Health Services decision to close the Minden emergency department “for a minimum of one year to allow for consultations with all affected stakeholders to occur.” (Photo: Patrick Porzuczek / Facebook)
Share on Bluesky
In their presentation, neither Plummer nor O’Brien addressed the criticisms levelled against Haliburton Highlands Health Services for the lack of communication and community consultation prior to announcing the decision or for the timing of the closure.
After the presentation, Carter raised the concern about a lack of communication, noting that previous discussions with Haliburton Highlands Health Services were only about staffing issues and the possibility of temporary closures of one or both emergency departments.
“At no point was there a discussion that one of these facilities would have to close permanently,” Carter said, adding he confirmed this by speaking with the other three mayors and four deputy mayors in the county. “Now in your mind that was perhaps the inevitability of what you were talking about, but there was no clear communication about that … This came as a complete shock to all of us.”
Carter then asked Plummer and O’Brien a question on behalf of the community about the key issues that led to the decision to permanently close the Minden emergency department.
Plummer reiterated that the primary reason is the lack of staff resources to maintain two emergency departments and the pressures on existing staff.
Share on Bluesky
“I can tell you that, heading into this summer, we would be otherwise facing multiple short-term, short-notice, unexpected closures of one if not both of our emergency departments at various unpredictable times, and it would be impossible to communicate properly to all the stakeholders and community members about those closures in sufficient time for them to know where to go in the event of an emergency,” Plummer said.
“We wanted to make sure that we could maintain emergency services in this county, and so we made the decision to consolidate them at a single site where we can bring our staff together to provide a more effective staffing coverage model to meet all the health care emergency needs of the county as a whole.”
Carter then asked why only six weeks’ notice was given of the closure, especially given the lack of prior communication to stakeholders and the upcoming summer season.
“It really was an operational decision that had to be made,” Plummer replied. “We had grave concerns as I said about the multiple, temporary, unpredictable closures that would have happened otherwise, and the significant risk that would place on the community in unpredictable ways as we would not be able to properly communication sufficiently ahead of those closures — some of those closures could happen with only two hours’ notice.”
Advertisement - content continues below
Share on Bluesky
“That’s how close we’ve come, and that was going to be a reality for this summer,” Plummer added. “We were able to make it through last summer, but just barely, and it was not going to be feasible for us to do that this summer.”
“This was a very, very difficult decision, and we know it’s been particularly difficult for the Minden community, but it was one we had to make in order to make sure that we still have (emergency) health services across the county as a whole and into the summer time.”
In response to another question from Carter, Plummer and O’Brien said the decision was made by the Haliburton Highlands Health Services board, supported by the hospital’s executive leadership team. The decision was communicated to the Ontario Ministry of Health and Long-Term Care, which was already aware of the staffing issues facing Haliburton Highlands Health Services.
After noting the “outpouring of concern from our community,” Carter asked if the June 1st date to close the Minden emergency department could “be pushed back to some reasonable time — November 1st, or later — so we could have a reasonable discussion, including all the stakeholders, and we can properly plan the implementation.”
“This would get us through the busy summer period and allow a transparent public process,” Carter added. “The question is, are you willing to agree, consider, or commit to pushing back this date?”
Plummer did not directly answer the question, but repeated that the decision was an operational one, to avoid “multiple temporary but short-notice closures (of) one or likely both emergency departments, all summer long,” and that it would be extremely difficult to properly notify the community of the closures, resulting in “much confusion, and that would have been unsafe for the community as a whole.”
Advertisement - content continues below
Carter asked what would happen, with the Minden emergency department closed, if the Haliburton emergency department has to temporarily close.
“This gives us the opportunity to shift all of our resources into one location, to help reduce the risk of that kind of closure happening,” Plummer replied. “The risk is always there, but this reduces that risk.”
Carter pointed out the decision to close the Minden emergency department in six weeks would have an unplanned impact on other emergency services in Minden, including paramedics and volunteer firefighters, who would be responding to medical calls, with an impact on cost — especially at the busiest time of year during the summer.
Deputy mayor Lisa Schell asked Plummer to confirm which location almost closed 20 times due to staffing issues, adding “keep in mind I know the answer. I would just like to hear your honest answer to everybody in this community, because most of us know what it is.”
“Those were all related to physician shortages at our Haliburton site,” Plummer replied. “Our Minden site is also now facing physician shortages. Both sites are facing physician shortages. What isn’t included in that 20-plus official notifications is the countless times that we’ve had nursing sick calls … it could be Haliburton, it could be Minden, it could be both. Depending on the situation, both emergency departments could be closed. We have faced that near possibility many, many times in the last 18 months — far more than 20. It happens probably weekly, maybe more often than that, but it happens regularly with our nursing sick calls and shortages of nursing staff.”
Schell then asked Plummer to name the stakeholders that Haliburton Highlands Health Services consulted with about the decision to close the Minden emergency department.
Plummer replied that the operational decision was made by the board, supported by the executive leadership team, “but informed by conversations with staff.” She added that the board has done “reach-outs with regard to our strategic plan” that involved anonymous surveys, interviews, and focus groups. (On Friday, in an interview on CBC Radio’s Ontario Morning, when host Ramraajh Sharvendiran asked if Haliburton Highlands Health Services consulted about a permanent closure, Plummer said “We did not ask about that specific question.”)
Later on Thursday afternoon, Plummer and O’Brien attended a special meeting of Haliburton County council to explain the rationale for the decision to close the Minden emergency department. While that meeting was closed to the public, council issued a statement the following day.
Share on Bluesky
“Council remains extremely concerned and dissatisfied in their decision and the timing associated with the closure,” the statement reads. “We also continue to be disappointed in the absence of communication between county council, the community and (Haliburton Highlands Health Services) over the last number of months while this step was being considered.”
“We will continue to advocate on behalf of our residents to ensure that (Haliburton Highlands Health Services) responds to questions about reorganization and ongoing service delivery in the county, including identifying and attracting services to work out of the Minden site. To that end council will be requesting that (Haliburton Highlands Health Services) present their implementation plan to combine emergency services at a special meeting in May.”
While Haliburton-Kawartha Lakes-Brock MPP Laurie Scott has not issued an official statement about the decision to close the Minden emergency department, Haliburton-Kawartha Lakes-Brock MP Jamie Schmale addressed the issue in Parliament on Thursday evening during a debate on the second reading of Bill C-47, the Budget Implementation Act.
Share on Bluesky
“Let me be clear, the decision made by the Haliburton Highlands Health Services Board of Directors is something I oppose,” Schmale wrote on Facebook. “We have been told that this decision, which I have no doubt was very difficult to make, was not based on financial considerations but was solely due to inadequate staffing levels.”
“As someone who grew up in Bobcaygeon and has used the Minden ER more than once, I join with residents and echo concern for their community hospital. While the decision was a local one, I recognize that the federal government has a role to play in facilitating the immigration of qualified nurses and doctors to address labour shortages not just in Minden but throughout the country.”
Minden resident and former Minden firefighter Patrick Porzuczek, who was at Queen’s Park on Thursday and also established the Facebook group and online petition, has also created a GoFundMe campaign that has raised over $4,600 to help fund community efforts to stop the closure.
Minden residents have also set up a new website called Minden Matters at mindenmatters.com.
kawarthaNOW.com offers two enews options to help readers stay in the know. Our VIP enews is delivered weekly every Wednesday morning and includes exclusive giveaways, and our news digest is delivered daily every morning. You can subscribe to one or both.
Submit your event for FREE!
Use our event submission form to post your event on our website — for free.
To submit editorial content or ideas, please contact us.